What do you think?
Rate this book
Belmont Mansion #1
A Lasting Impression
To create something that will last is Claire Laurent's most fervent desire as an artist. It's also her greatest weakness. When her fraud of a father deals her an unexpected hand, Claire is forced to flee from New Orleans to Nashville, only a year after the War Between the States has ended. Claire's path collides with that of Sutton Monroe, and she considers him a godsend for not turning her in to the authorities. But when they meet again and he refuses to come to her aid, she realizes she's sorely misjudged the man. Trading an unwanted destiny for an unknown future, Claire finds herself in the middle of Nashville's elite society and believes her dream of creating a lasting impression in the world of art may finally be within reach.
All that Sutton Monroe holds dear lies in ruin. He's determined to reclaim his heritage and to make the men who murdered his father pay. But what he discovers on his quest for vengeance reveals a truth that may cost him more than he ever imagined.
Set at Nashville's historic 1850s Belmont Mansion, a stunning antebellum manor built by Mrs. Adelicia Acklen, the richest woman in America in the 1860s, A Lasting Impression showcases the deep, poignant, unforgettable characters that set Tamera's stories apart and provides an inspiring love story that will capture readers' hearts and leave them eager for more.
All that Sutton Monroe holds dear lies in ruin. He's determined to reclaim his heritage and to make the men who murdered his father pay. But what he discovers on his quest for vengeance reveals a truth that may cost him more than he ever imagined.
Set at Nashville's historic 1850s Belmont Mansion, a stunning antebellum manor built by Mrs. Adelicia Acklen, the richest woman in America in the 1860s, A Lasting Impression showcases the deep, poignant, unforgettable characters that set Tamera's stories apart and provides an inspiring love story that will capture readers' hearts and leave them eager for more.
432 pages, Paperback
First published October 15, 2011
About the author
Tamera Alexander
30 books2,969 followersTamera Alexander is a USA Today bestselling author and one of today's most popular writers in the inspirational historical fiction genre. She and her husband live in Nashville, Tennessee, not far from the Southern mansions that serve as the backdrop for six of her award-winning novels.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 655 reviews
April 5, 2024
5 stars!
A Lasting Impression (2011, Bethany House) is #1 in the Belmont Mansion series by Tamera Alexander. It's a historical Christian romance with a touch of mystery and suspense, set at Belmont Mansion in Nashville, Tennessee in 1866.
Heroine:
Claire Laurent is the daughter of an art gallery owner in New Orleans. Her father's art gallery specializes in original pieces by master artists, many of which are actually painted by Claire. Claire does not like forging paintings, but feels forced by her father. When things get too hot, it's time to flee. After going to Nashville under the direction of her father's business partner, she is unhappy with what she finds at the address he gives her. So she flees again, seeking safety in a church. While there, she overhears two women speaking of an available position as personal liason to the wealthy Adelicia Acklen.
Hero:
Sutton Monroe is a lawyer in a firm in Nashville, as well as the manager and lawyer for Mrs. Acklen's interests. He advises Adelicia against hiring Claire because she's not the most qualified lady for the position, but "The Lady" takes a liking to Claire and hires her anyway on a trial basis.
What I like:
As I've come to expect with Ms. Alexander, this book has a rich background that was not only obviously well-researched, but is extremely interesting. The primary characters have depth, and many of the secondary ones do too. Claire and Sutton grow closer throughout the book, and an issue that could have been such a barrier between them was handled so very well. Hats off to Tamera Alexander, because I kept wondering how it was possibly going to work out.
What I didn't like:
There are other romantic interests in the story. I'm going to be intentionally vague to avoid spoilers. I am never very fond of more than one love interest in a romance, but Ms. Alexander did a nice job with it, and I was only mildly irritated. :-)
----------------------
I'd recommend this book to fans of Christian historical fiction/romance. It's such a rich story. My husband also read this book, and agreed that it was very good! (He doesn't usually read my books.) I did read the next book and loved that one also. See my review:
A Beauty So Rare
------------------
The timeline of the Belle Meade Plantation and Belmont Mansion series are intertwined. (They’re very near each other in Nashville.) At the bottom of this review, I’ve listed the six books (and one novella) of the two series in what I believe to be the chronologically correct order. (A Beauty So Rare actually ends up being third in the sequence of seven stories.) For your convenience, see the list below.
A Lasting Impression, (Belmont Mansion #1, published 2011)
To Whisper Her Name (Belle Meade Plantation #1, published 2012)
A Beauty So Rare (Belmont Mansion, #2, 2014) (set in 1868)
To Win Her Favor , (Belle Meade Plantation #2, published 2015) (set in 1869-1870)
To Mend a Dream , (Belle Meade #2.5, published 2015 in Among the Fair Magnolias )
A Note Yet Unsung , (Belmont Mansion #3, 2017)
To Wager Her Heart , (Belle Meade Plantation #3, 2017)
---------------------------
Update (11/25/18): Some new information and formatting added.
A Lasting Impression (2011, Bethany House) is #1 in the Belmont Mansion series by Tamera Alexander. It's a historical Christian romance with a touch of mystery and suspense, set at Belmont Mansion in Nashville, Tennessee in 1866.
Heroine:
Claire Laurent is the daughter of an art gallery owner in New Orleans. Her father's art gallery specializes in original pieces by master artists, many of which are actually painted by Claire. Claire does not like forging paintings, but feels forced by her father. When things get too hot, it's time to flee. After going to Nashville under the direction of her father's business partner, she is unhappy with what she finds at the address he gives her. So she flees again, seeking safety in a church. While there, she overhears two women speaking of an available position as personal liason to the wealthy Adelicia Acklen.
Hero:
Sutton Monroe is a lawyer in a firm in Nashville, as well as the manager and lawyer for Mrs. Acklen's interests. He advises Adelicia against hiring Claire because she's not the most qualified lady for the position, but "The Lady" takes a liking to Claire and hires her anyway on a trial basis.
What I like:
As I've come to expect with Ms. Alexander, this book has a rich background that was not only obviously well-researched, but is extremely interesting. The primary characters have depth, and many of the secondary ones do too. Claire and Sutton grow closer throughout the book, and an issue that could have been such a barrier between them was handled so very well. Hats off to Tamera Alexander, because I kept wondering how it was possibly going to work out.
What I didn't like:
There are other romantic interests in the story. I'm going to be intentionally vague to avoid spoilers. I am never very fond of more than one love interest in a romance, but Ms. Alexander did a nice job with it, and I was only mildly irritated. :-)
----------------------
I'd recommend this book to fans of Christian historical fiction/romance. It's such a rich story. My husband also read this book, and agreed that it was very good! (He doesn't usually read my books.) I did read the next book and loved that one also. See my review:
A Beauty So Rare
------------------
The timeline of the Belle Meade Plantation and Belmont Mansion series are intertwined. (They’re very near each other in Nashville.) At the bottom of this review, I’ve listed the six books (and one novella) of the two series in what I believe to be the chronologically correct order. (A Beauty So Rare actually ends up being third in the sequence of seven stories.) For your convenience, see the list below.
A Lasting Impression, (Belmont Mansion #1, published 2011)
To Whisper Her Name (Belle Meade Plantation #1, published 2012)
A Beauty So Rare (Belmont Mansion, #2, 2014) (set in 1868)
To Win Her Favor , (Belle Meade Plantation #2, published 2015) (set in 1869-1870)
To Mend a Dream , (Belle Meade #2.5, published 2015 in Among the Fair Magnolias )
A Note Yet Unsung , (Belmont Mansion #3, 2017)
To Wager Her Heart , (Belle Meade Plantation #3, 2017)
---------------------------
Update (11/25/18): Some new information and formatting added.
September 12, 2021
4.5 ⭐️
This is a series that I read out of order..I read this one last and it’s actually the first! Each book can definitely be read as a stand alone, but it would be more enjoyable to read in sequence as familiar characters from the other books will make appearances.
I think I would say…Tamera Alexander is my ‘comfort read’ author. When I don’t know where to go with picking up my next book, I can count on her to bring me something satisfying. She hits all the sweet spots for me—an enticing and unpredictable romantic story, great dialogue and character development, amazing spiritual wisdom and acknowledgment of the Lord/Biblical truths and realistic circumstances.
This book had all of the above and then some! I found myself caught up in each of the ‘situations’ that were going on, so curious to ‘hear’ how the characters relationships would develop and I so loved the honest dialogue that occurred between all characters, it was so true to life— that’s really refreshing. In my opinion, Tamera Alexander never capitalizes on big, predictable and dramatic situations but rather adds layers and depth; having her characters deal with circumstances in a realistic and mature way and I absolutely love that.
The heroine, Claire, may be one of my favorite characters in all of Tamera’s books so far. She has such an endearing and fun personality and was so tender hearted. The relationship that develops between her and the hero, Sutton, was so sweet to watch unfold. I also loved the fantastic descriptions of the artwork mentioned in this story, I looked it all up as I read. The history in this book is very interesting. If I find myself in TN, I’m heading to the Belmont Mansion!
This is a series that I read out of order..I read this one last and it’s actually the first! Each book can definitely be read as a stand alone, but it would be more enjoyable to read in sequence as familiar characters from the other books will make appearances.
I think I would say…Tamera Alexander is my ‘comfort read’ author. When I don’t know where to go with picking up my next book, I can count on her to bring me something satisfying. She hits all the sweet spots for me—an enticing and unpredictable romantic story, great dialogue and character development, amazing spiritual wisdom and acknowledgment of the Lord/Biblical truths and realistic circumstances.
This book had all of the above and then some! I found myself caught up in each of the ‘situations’ that were going on, so curious to ‘hear’ how the characters relationships would develop and I so loved the honest dialogue that occurred between all characters, it was so true to life— that’s really refreshing. In my opinion, Tamera Alexander never capitalizes on big, predictable and dramatic situations but rather adds layers and depth; having her characters deal with circumstances in a realistic and mature way and I absolutely love that.
The heroine, Claire, may be one of my favorite characters in all of Tamera’s books so far. She has such an endearing and fun personality and was so tender hearted. The relationship that develops between her and the hero, Sutton, was so sweet to watch unfold. I also loved the fantastic descriptions of the artwork mentioned in this story, I looked it all up as I read. The history in this book is very interesting. If I find myself in TN, I’m heading to the Belmont Mansion!
November 14, 2011
First posted on my blog, Legacy of a Writer.
Wow. Words seem so inadequate to express just how rich this book is—both in historical details and the romantic tension. I can't remember exactly, but it's been a while since a book touched me so emotionally; I was fighting tears at times. But therein is the beauty of Tamera Alexander's new release, A Lasting Impression—her writing touches to the heart.
And the writing! Tamera's style was beautiful and brought to life the Belmont mansion as seen through Claire's eyes. The depth and realistic qualities she gives each and every character in this book was amazing. Claire was such an amazing person and I grew so close to her over the course of the novel. I was sad when I read the last page and had to say good bye to her and dear, fun-loving Sutton. She'd had such a sad life before coming to Belmont, and had many things to overcome. But I enjoyed watching her meet, and overcome, every challenge.
The Christian elements in the book were wonderful. Tamera wove it seamlessly into the plot and did it so gradually; it felt more realistic and believable than many other books I've read. And not in a preachy way, either. Claire's gradual, but very sincere, search for salvation and redemption was so touching—and when the Lord finally opened her eyes...I felt like crying for joy. How beautiful!
There have been some very good historical fictions published this year, but few have really stood out from the others and made it to my ‘favorites’ shelf for 2011. But A Lasting Impression has done just that—sitting proudly beside my copies of The Doctor's Lady and The Measure of Katie Calloway. Cracking open the cover to this book is like stepping back in time to the wonderful world of high-society and fine art that decorated the halls of Belmont mansion.
Wow. Words seem so inadequate to express just how rich this book is—both in historical details and the romantic tension. I can't remember exactly, but it's been a while since a book touched me so emotionally; I was fighting tears at times. But therein is the beauty of Tamera Alexander's new release, A Lasting Impression—her writing touches to the heart.
And the writing! Tamera's style was beautiful and brought to life the Belmont mansion as seen through Claire's eyes. The depth and realistic qualities she gives each and every character in this book was amazing. Claire was such an amazing person and I grew so close to her over the course of the novel. I was sad when I read the last page and had to say good bye to her and dear, fun-loving Sutton. She'd had such a sad life before coming to Belmont, and had many things to overcome. But I enjoyed watching her meet, and overcome, every challenge.
The Christian elements in the book were wonderful. Tamera wove it seamlessly into the plot and did it so gradually; it felt more realistic and believable than many other books I've read. And not in a preachy way, either. Claire's gradual, but very sincere, search for salvation and redemption was so touching—and when the Lord finally opened her eyes...I felt like crying for joy. How beautiful!
There have been some very good historical fictions published this year, but few have really stood out from the others and made it to my ‘favorites’ shelf for 2011. But A Lasting Impression has done just that—sitting proudly beside my copies of The Doctor's Lady and The Measure of Katie Calloway. Cracking open the cover to this book is like stepping back in time to the wonderful world of high-society and fine art that decorated the halls of Belmont mansion.
December 23, 2016
**Originally posted on Reveries Reviews**
AH THIS BOOK WAS SO AMAZING!!!!!!!!!
Okay, I’d better calm down and write an orderly review of this fantastic book which I adore and want to read again and again and again and again …
So … yep.
First, Belmont … gorgeous. I want to live there. I need to live there!
Second, Adelicia Acklen. Amazing character. She was a real person who actually lived and some of the words she said in the book were written by her in a letter to someone! That’s so cool! She has a really sad past. Really, really incredible woman. Wow, wow, wow!
Claire is a fantastic character! I love how hard-working she is, how good she is at her job. Her job is one to die for … although I definitely couldn’t do it. Her creativity in the party and all other things is fantastic. Just … wow.
Sutton is also a great character. I feel like he wasn’t as focused on as Claire, but he was still great. I really liked him.
As I mentioned before, the setting was once-again amazing; Tamera Alexander is always great at putting you in a place you want to live and that you see in a very vivid way. The characters were all well-developed (I love most of them and hate the others, which is how it’s supposed to be). The plot was great. There was a little back-and-forth between Claire and Sutton that I didn’t care, but yeah, otherwise, is was a fantastic book.
And … I have no negatives.
I’m just going to publish this (once-again, pretty short) review as I’m not feeling particularly creative. It was fantastic, I’d recommend it to any lover of historical fiction, sweet romances, lush settings, or intriguing plots.
~Kellyn Roth, Reveries Reviews
AH THIS BOOK WAS SO AMAZING!!!!!!!!!
Okay, I’d better calm down and write an orderly review of this fantastic book which I adore and want to read again and again and again and again …
So … yep.
First, Belmont … gorgeous. I want to live there. I need to live there!
Second, Adelicia Acklen. Amazing character. She was a real person who actually lived and some of the words she said in the book were written by her in a letter to someone! That’s so cool! She has a really sad past. Really, really incredible woman. Wow, wow, wow!
Claire is a fantastic character! I love how hard-working she is, how good she is at her job. Her job is one to die for … although I definitely couldn’t do it. Her creativity in the party and all other things is fantastic. Just … wow.
Sutton is also a great character. I feel like he wasn’t as focused on as Claire, but he was still great. I really liked him.
As I mentioned before, the setting was once-again amazing; Tamera Alexander is always great at putting you in a place you want to live and that you see in a very vivid way. The characters were all well-developed (I love most of them and hate the others, which is how it’s supposed to be). The plot was great. There was a little back-and-forth between Claire and Sutton that I didn’t care, but yeah, otherwise, is was a fantastic book.
And … I have no negatives.
I’m just going to publish this (once-again, pretty short) review as I’m not feeling particularly creative. It was fantastic, I’d recommend it to any lover of historical fiction, sweet romances, lush settings, or intriguing plots.
~Kellyn Roth, Reveries Reviews
December 17, 2021
5 stars ✨
“We should not expect to have all the blessings of life and none of its trials. It would make this world too delightful a dwelling place, and I fear we would never care to leave it.” Her eyes slipped closed. “As it is . . . I have come to believe that it’s only by taking some of those objects from us to which our hearts so closely cling that He endeavors . . . in His kindness, to draw us from this world to one of greater happiness.”
The one word I have for this book is RICH. It was so beautiful and detailed I felt as if I were watching it unfold, rather than reading it. The romance was just enough, clean and perfect, the history was like butter slowly melting in Tennessee. Im a southerner and love books that bring me closer to my roots. Reading along as Claire overcame her past and fought through finding her place was like a breath of fresh air.
This was my first book by this author and she’s gained a new follower. Her writing is masterful and like art itself. I loved everything about A Lasting Impression and look forward to reading the rest of The Belmont series.
“We should not expect to have all the blessings of life and none of its trials. It would make this world too delightful a dwelling place, and I fear we would never care to leave it.” Her eyes slipped closed. “As it is . . . I have come to believe that it’s only by taking some of those objects from us to which our hearts so closely cling that He endeavors . . . in His kindness, to draw us from this world to one of greater happiness.”
The one word I have for this book is RICH. It was so beautiful and detailed I felt as if I were watching it unfold, rather than reading it. The romance was just enough, clean and perfect, the history was like butter slowly melting in Tennessee. Im a southerner and love books that bring me closer to my roots. Reading along as Claire overcame her past and fought through finding her place was like a breath of fresh air.
This was my first book by this author and she’s gained a new follower. Her writing is masterful and like art itself. I loved everything about A Lasting Impression and look forward to reading the rest of The Belmont series.
November 12, 2011
A Lasting Impression is a wonderful start to a new series. With writing that is rich and textured, Ms. Alexander paints a portrait of Belmont and Nashville after the Civil War that will pull you in and almost make you believe that you are living there yourself.
March 17, 2012
Oh. My. I don't even know where to begin to write a review that can do justice to Tamera Alexander's latest masterpiece. When I opened this book, I knew I was in for a treat, and I still managed to be overwhelmed by it. Tammy is truly one of the most gifted authors I have read, and A Lasting Impression is her best novel yet. Just as a black and white sketch is only a faint depiction of a painting, the summary above can only give a glimpse into the outline of this book. Tamera Alexander brings life and color to these characters and this setting, not with brush and palette, but with words painted across the page. I found myself having a tug of war as I read: wanting to practically inhale the book to discover what happened next, yet also wanting to linger and stretch it out, making the story last as long as possible. Her characters practically step off the page - they are that well-portrayed. Claire's heartaches and fears, as well as her hopes and joys, are palpable, and I felt every one of her emotions as I read. Mrs. Adelicia Franklin Acklen made me sit up straight and proper; she was quite intimidating. And I absolutely quaked whenever Mrs. Routh, the housekeeper, walked into the room! That woman made my heart pound! The historical detail and the setting are richly depicted and neither heavy nor laborious, as some historical fiction novels can be. In fact, several times as I read, I found myself stopping to reread a portion because the prose was so breathtaking. Yet it never felt overdone or as if Tammy had just dumped a thesaurus onto the page! Beautiful spiritual truths are woven seamlessly into the story and give it a depth which makes it more than simply a pleasant read. Deceit, despair, forgiveness, redemption, faith, trust, and love make this an incredible novel. I think this is the first book I've ever read that I've been sorely tempted to immediately begin again reading Chapter One as soon as I turned the final page! I reflected on the characters and the message of the book for days; it definitely made A Lasting Impression on me!
April 26, 2023
Reread 2023
4.5 stars rounded to 5 (I think).
I am loving rereading Tamera's books. Since it's been a few years, it's as if I'm discovering them all over again. I went into this one not really sure of what it was about, but as I was reading I came across scenes that I did remember.
This book is full of fleshed-out characters, incredible descriptions, and a realistic, character-driven plot. I really liked Sutton, and Claire + her internal struggles were also very well-done. Out of all her books, this is the one I remembered least, yet it surprised me how good it was. (It really shouldn't; Tamera knows what she's doing!). Book 2 in this series is my favourite, so I'm very excited to pick that one up next!
4.5 stars rounded to 5 (I think).
I am loving rereading Tamera's books. Since it's been a few years, it's as if I'm discovering them all over again. I went into this one not really sure of what it was about, but as I was reading I came across scenes that I did remember.
This book is full of fleshed-out characters, incredible descriptions, and a realistic, character-driven plot. I really liked Sutton, and Claire + her internal struggles were also very well-done. Out of all her books, this is the one I remembered least, yet it surprised me how good it was. (It really shouldn't; Tamera knows what she's doing!). Book 2 in this series is my favourite, so I'm very excited to pick that one up next!
August 24, 2023
I enjoyed a second visit to Belmont Mansion courtesy of the audible edition narrated by Linda Stephens. As intriguing as the first time I read it.
---
Richly layered and impeccably crafted, this is definitely a book that will make a lasting impression on its readers! Rich in history, Alexander manages to bring the post-civil war era to life. I could feel the conflicting spirits of hope and despair; the division of a people and the lingering taste of bitterness in a defeated state. My emotions ran amok as I read! In fact I was left half-dreading each page the deeper I got into the book because I knew that Claire's secret couldn't stay buried forever but Alexander spun the reveal out with the expertise of a skilled storyteller and I was on tenterhooks the entire time. Brilliantly done.
The historical detail is brilliant as well. It stirred me to do my own research on Belmont Mansion and Mrs. Acklen. I love when fiction and non-fiction meet in a delicious way like this! It makes my reading experience all the more fulfilling.
And the romance -- oh-la-la! Sutton makes a fainting couch a must have for this read! LOL. Loved the way Alexander develops the attraction between Claire and Sutton and she put enough stumbling blocks in the way to keep this reader's heart dipping and diving for the duration of the read.
A Lasting Impression has the classic feel of an epic novel. It's the kind of book that carries you away to a different time and place -- immerses you in the story and leaves you richer for the read.
https://kavsbestreads.ca/2023/08/24/a...
---
Richly layered and impeccably crafted, this is definitely a book that will make a lasting impression on its readers! Rich in history, Alexander manages to bring the post-civil war era to life. I could feel the conflicting spirits of hope and despair; the division of a people and the lingering taste of bitterness in a defeated state. My emotions ran amok as I read! In fact I was left half-dreading each page the deeper I got into the book because I knew that Claire's secret couldn't stay buried forever but Alexander spun the reveal out with the expertise of a skilled storyteller and I was on tenterhooks the entire time. Brilliantly done.
The historical detail is brilliant as well. It stirred me to do my own research on Belmont Mansion and Mrs. Acklen. I love when fiction and non-fiction meet in a delicious way like this! It makes my reading experience all the more fulfilling.
And the romance -- oh-la-la! Sutton makes a fainting couch a must have for this read! LOL. Loved the way Alexander develops the attraction between Claire and Sutton and she put enough stumbling blocks in the way to keep this reader's heart dipping and diving for the duration of the read.
A Lasting Impression has the classic feel of an epic novel. It's the kind of book that carries you away to a different time and place -- immerses you in the story and leaves you richer for the read.
https://kavsbestreads.ca/2023/08/24/a...
September 6, 2020
This is an easy-breezy read of romance with a bit of suspense. It didn't feel as lame as most romance novels which I shy away from like the plague, this one I totally enjoyed. I immediately cheered for the heroine as she tried desperately to escape her difficult circumstances in the very beginning. While there is a touch of Christianity weaved within the story it was not overpowering and I would not call this book a Christian novel. I loved the idea of taking a real stately mansion and creating a story around it and its owners and look forward to more novels set at Belmont Mansion by this author. As soon as I finished the book I immediately looked at the Belmont Mansion web site and was not disappointed, Ms Alexander did it proud. I truly recommend this book - it will leave you with a happy heart and a smile on your face and a great desire to visit the real Belmont Mansion.
July 8, 2018
That was unexpectedly lovely, and I did not mean to finish it tonight.
I first started it about a month and a half ago, right during the onslaught of the Reading Slump that Shall Go Down in Infamy. I wasn't feeling it, then - but it was honestly not because of the book. It just wasn't the right time.
So when I picked it up today? I DID NOT EXPECT TO GET SO HOOKED.
Lovely Things:
- The setting is so vivid. SOMEONE PLEASE TAKE ME TO BELMONT MANSION, PLEASE AND THANK YOU.
- The writing. It's everything I've come to expect of Tamera Alexander! (Although not as good as in A Note Yet Unsung . . . but then again, nothing is as good as A Note Yet Unsung. ;P)
- THE BANTER HAD ME CRACKING UP OH MY GOODNESS
- Claire and Sutton's relationship was SO NATURAL and adorable and real. It wasn't overly dramatic or insta-lovey (totally a word). It overdid it a bit in the uh, flirting and physical contact area . . . but it was nonetheless absolutely adorable. They had such a sweet relationship, and it warmed my heart.
- ahhhhhhHHHHH ALL THE ART STUFF <3333
- Claire is French and Sutton is southern and somehow that strikes me as the cutest match. I don't even know why, but it does.
- Can we talk about the themes? 'Cause I'm here for them.
- That scene when they got up in the night and made breakfast? I shipped them so hard.
- Claire was honestly one of the most refreshing female characters I've ever read. She was incredibly hardworking and desired to make a new name for herself. Sweet yet with a steely resolve and a sharp wit. Timid at first, but gradually, her confidence grew and it was a beautiful sight to behold. Gentle and kind and so gracious when people put her down. But she wasn't a pushover either. Guys - Claire was just wonderful. (But she's not perfect . . . don't worry.)
- Tamera Alexander gets an A+++ for character development, just sayin'.
- OKAY I REALLY LIKED THIS BOOK. THAT IS ALL.
Not-So-Lovely Things:
- Really, there's not much . . . but it didn't quite resonate with me the way I hoped it would. I had kind of an, "aww, that was sweet" reaction at the end, which was far different from the POWERFUL emotion I felt during A Note Yet Unsung (sorry, I can't help comparing them). An excellent book, but it missed the mark of becoming a favorite.
- While I adored the romance and thought their teasing banter was cute, it DID kind of get a bit too flirty and physically-based sometimes. They could have eased off the kissing and touching a leetle bit. :P It made me a bit uncomfortable at times, but not to an extreme degree.
- I was hoping the plot would take a bit more of a dramatic turn than it did. No spoilers, but it didn't seem like it built up to as much in certain areas as I was hoping it would.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and am immensely glad I came back to it! Though it's nowhere near as good as A Note Yet Unsung, in my opinion, it stands well on its own as a truly wonderful read.
4 stars!
I first started it about a month and a half ago, right during the onslaught of the Reading Slump that Shall Go Down in Infamy. I wasn't feeling it, then - but it was honestly not because of the book. It just wasn't the right time.
So when I picked it up today? I DID NOT EXPECT TO GET SO HOOKED.
Lovely Things:
- The setting is so vivid. SOMEONE PLEASE TAKE ME TO BELMONT MANSION, PLEASE AND THANK YOU.
- The writing. It's everything I've come to expect of Tamera Alexander! (Although not as good as in A Note Yet Unsung . . . but then again, nothing is as good as A Note Yet Unsung. ;P)
- THE BANTER HAD ME CRACKING UP OH MY GOODNESS
- Claire and Sutton's relationship was SO NATURAL and adorable and real. It wasn't overly dramatic or insta-lovey (totally a word). It overdid it a bit in the uh, flirting and physical contact area . . . but it was nonetheless absolutely adorable. They had such a sweet relationship, and it warmed my heart.
- ahhhhhhHHHHH ALL THE ART STUFF <3333
- Claire is French and Sutton is southern and somehow that strikes me as the cutest match. I don't even know why, but it does.
- Can we talk about the themes? 'Cause I'm here for them.
- That scene when they got up in the night and made breakfast? I shipped them so hard.
- Claire was honestly one of the most refreshing female characters I've ever read. She was incredibly hardworking and desired to make a new name for herself. Sweet yet with a steely resolve and a sharp wit. Timid at first, but gradually, her confidence grew and it was a beautiful sight to behold. Gentle and kind and so gracious when people put her down. But she wasn't a pushover either. Guys - Claire was just wonderful. (But she's not perfect . . . don't worry.)
- Tamera Alexander gets an A+++ for character development, just sayin'.
- OKAY I REALLY LIKED THIS BOOK. THAT IS ALL.
Not-So-Lovely Things:
- Really, there's not much . . . but it didn't quite resonate with me the way I hoped it would. I had kind of an, "aww, that was sweet" reaction at the end, which was far different from the POWERFUL emotion I felt during A Note Yet Unsung (sorry, I can't help comparing them). An excellent book, but it missed the mark of becoming a favorite.
- While I adored the romance and thought their teasing banter was cute, it DID kind of get a bit too flirty and physically-based sometimes. They could have eased off the kissing and touching a leetle bit. :P It made me a bit uncomfortable at times, but not to an extreme degree.
- I was hoping the plot would take a bit more of a dramatic turn than it did. No spoilers, but it didn't seem like it built up to as much in certain areas as I was hoping it would.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and am immensely glad I came back to it! Though it's nowhere near as good as A Note Yet Unsung, in my opinion, it stands well on its own as a truly wonderful read.
4 stars!
July 17, 2016
A Lasting Impression is about Claire Laurant, a young woman who seeks to bury her past of forging paintings for her father. Sent to Nashville, Tennessee after a threatening incident at her family's art gallery, Claire soon gets a job at Belmont Mansion, home of the extremely wealthy Adelicia Acklen. There she builds herself a new life, a life that could get her to her dream- to paint a something the world would notice. But soon she determines that she must tell the truth to those who have come to trust her, no matter what might happen...
This book was a very good historical account of the days after the Civil War. And Belmont Mansion? Mrs. Acklen really existed, and the mansion still stand in Nashville today! I did a little "research" online while reading this book, and seeing the pictures of Belmont and Adelicia kind of put the story I was reading to life! It was cool. :)
Reading about living in such a wealthy atmosphere and such a grand place was interesting. All the grand parties, and everything.
The artistic aspects of this story were interesting as well. :)
Claire was a pretty good character. :) I think she was fairly relatable to me.
I liked Sutton for the most part. I like the name: Sutton Monroe. :D But I probably liked him better before they really fell in love, because the romance wasn't quite my favorite type. Some of Sutton's actions and thoughts didn't seem quite gentlemanly... enough. Or maybe slightly inappropriate. Like "caressing her shoulders" (she was wearing an off-the-shoulder dress), and telling her to promise she'd wear it every week or something. Err... There were just some little things that I didn't really think were necessary. Personally, I prefer more sweet romances, without so much kissing and "romantic banter". :P But I did like Sutton. :)
And the end was cute. :D
There is one character that you wish Claire would kick out the door at this certain point. He is SO HORRID. You'll see.
So all in all, an enjoyable, interesting historical read!
As for the ages I'd recommend this book for? Maybe 16 and up? There was a lot of kissing and romance, so mature audience there (it may have been a bit much for me, not having read much romance, but it wasn't bad). There was a stabbing as well, and a man with dishonorable intentions who Claire had to run from, so, yea.
This book was a very good historical account of the days after the Civil War. And Belmont Mansion? Mrs. Acklen really existed, and the mansion still stand in Nashville today! I did a little "research" online while reading this book, and seeing the pictures of Belmont and Adelicia kind of put the story I was reading to life! It was cool. :)
Reading about living in such a wealthy atmosphere and such a grand place was interesting. All the grand parties, and everything.
The artistic aspects of this story were interesting as well. :)
Claire was a pretty good character. :) I think she was fairly relatable to me.
I liked Sutton for the most part. I like the name: Sutton Monroe. :D But I probably liked him better before they really fell in love, because the romance wasn't quite my favorite type. Some of Sutton's actions and thoughts didn't seem quite gentlemanly... enough. Or maybe slightly inappropriate. Like "caressing her shoulders" (she was wearing an off-the-shoulder dress), and telling her to promise she'd wear it every week or something. Err... There were just some little things that I didn't really think were necessary. Personally, I prefer more sweet romances, without so much kissing and "romantic banter". :P But I did like Sutton. :)
And the end was cute. :D
There is one character that you wish Claire would kick out the door at this certain point. He is SO HORRID. You'll see.
So all in all, an enjoyable, interesting historical read!
As for the ages I'd recommend this book for? Maybe 16 and up? There was a lot of kissing and romance, so mature audience there (it may have been a bit much for me, not having read much romance, but it wasn't bad). There was a stabbing as well, and a man with dishonorable intentions who Claire had to run from, so, yea.
March 23, 2023
Absolutely loved this book. Fascinating characters, an intricate plot, and a setting full of history that comes alive make for a memorable story. Tamara Alexander has written a beautiful story that touches the heart and lingers in your thoughts.
My 2014 review:
Why have I waited this long to read a Tamera Alexander book? I completely loved it and I can't wait to get my hands on another one of her books! Ms. Alexander has a beautiful writing style that captured me. She is able to paint a picture with her beautiful words, just as the main character, Claire, paints pictures on canvas. Her writing is rich and layered, which made my reading experience truly enjoyable. From the setting, to the history, to the plot and characterization, Tamera Alexander has written a book that has lingered in my thoughts over the last few days.
Claire Laurent is desperately trying to leave the past behind. It is made up of bad memories and she wants to start fresh with her life. But her secret always seems to be lurking around the corner. Sutton Monroe has lost a lot in recent years, and the pain of it all threatens to make him bitter. But Claire breaths new life into his world. As Claire and Sutton get to know one another, will they be able to share a life together and move forward? Or will the past tear them apart?
This story shows that the past does not define you, nor should you let it. Rather, let God define who you are. The journey that Claire goes on in this book is one of redemption and forgiveness, as she learns from her mistakes and grows into a beautiful woman, both on the inside and the outside.
One last thing I wanted to discuss: Mrs. Adelicia Acklen. In one word, I would describeher as enigmatic. She intrigued me throughout the novel. She is a prominent woman who is confident and expects the best from the people around her. She is direct and honest, and never shies away from speaking her thoughts. Yet, she is also a loving woman who cares deeply for her children and loved ones. And as you discover the pain of her past, you symapthize with her and discover her heart. A beautiful character that I very much enjoyed reading about.
My 2014 review:
Why have I waited this long to read a Tamera Alexander book? I completely loved it and I can't wait to get my hands on another one of her books! Ms. Alexander has a beautiful writing style that captured me. She is able to paint a picture with her beautiful words, just as the main character, Claire, paints pictures on canvas. Her writing is rich and layered, which made my reading experience truly enjoyable. From the setting, to the history, to the plot and characterization, Tamera Alexander has written a book that has lingered in my thoughts over the last few days.
Claire Laurent is desperately trying to leave the past behind. It is made up of bad memories and she wants to start fresh with her life. But her secret always seems to be lurking around the corner. Sutton Monroe has lost a lot in recent years, and the pain of it all threatens to make him bitter. But Claire breaths new life into his world. As Claire and Sutton get to know one another, will they be able to share a life together and move forward? Or will the past tear them apart?
This story shows that the past does not define you, nor should you let it. Rather, let God define who you are. The journey that Claire goes on in this book is one of redemption and forgiveness, as she learns from her mistakes and grows into a beautiful woman, both on the inside and the outside.
One last thing I wanted to discuss: Mrs. Adelicia Acklen. In one word, I would describeher as enigmatic. She intrigued me throughout the novel. She is a prominent woman who is confident and expects the best from the people around her. She is direct and honest, and never shies away from speaking her thoughts. Yet, she is also a loving woman who cares deeply for her children and loved ones. And as you discover the pain of her past, you symapthize with her and discover her heart. A beautiful character that I very much enjoyed reading about.
February 19, 2020
Tammy is a special author to me, and it's not just because we share the same school history with a private school in Georgia or the southern hospitality spirit. It's because of that and because her stories get under your skin and in to your heart. Her characters are real and leap from the page. I was captivated by every series I have read so far, pretty much from page one. I have lost many a night sleep or day's chore lacked accomplishment simply because I was too distraught by the idea of leaving the plot and protagonist until I found out what happened next.
It's amazing to me, how Tammy can find characters with a slight bit of past that makes you really want to not like them, and walk on the other side of the road... but she finds ways to bring them into your hearts and they are then the ones that you are mentally cheering for as you turn each page. Reading this Belmont Mansion Novel, I could hear the southern drawl and it makes me smile. A native Georgian, southern through and through now relocated to Tennessee -- I definitely found things within these pages to endure and entertain.
*Thanks to Bethany House Publishers and Litfuse Publicity for providing a copy for review.*
Originally posted: http://creativemadnessmama.com/blog/2...
It's amazing to me, how Tammy can find characters with a slight bit of past that makes you really want to not like them, and walk on the other side of the road... but she finds ways to bring them into your hearts and they are then the ones that you are mentally cheering for as you turn each page. Reading this Belmont Mansion Novel, I could hear the southern drawl and it makes me smile. A native Georgian, southern through and through now relocated to Tennessee -- I definitely found things within these pages to endure and entertain.
*Thanks to Bethany House Publishers and Litfuse Publicity for providing a copy for review.*
Originally posted: http://creativemadnessmama.com/blog/2...
October 16, 2020
I adore Tamera Alexander's books and this has become one of my favorites! If you enjoy her work or are interested in trying out historical fiction and a story full of faith be sure to check this one out!
March 27, 2014
About this book:
“To create something that will last is Claire Laurent's most fervent desire as an artist. It's also her greatest weakness. When her fraud of a father deals her an unexpected hand, Claire is forced to flee from New Orleans to Nashville, only a year after the War Between the States has ended. Claire's path collides with that of Sutton Monroe, and she considers him a godsend for not turning her in to the authorities. But when they meet again and he refuses to come to her aid, she realizes she's sorely misjudged the man. Trading an unwanted destiny for an unknown future, Claire finds herself in the middle of Nashville's elite society and believes her dream of creating a lasting impression in the world of art may finally be within reach.
All that Sutton Monroe holds dear lies in ruin. He's determined to reclaim his heritage and to make the men who murdered his father pay. But what he discovers on his quest for vengeance reveals a truth that may cost him more than he ever imagined.”
Series: “Belmont Mansion” book #1. Can be a stand-alone novel. (book #2, “A Beauty So Rare”’s review will be posted next Wednesday.)
Spiritual Content- Ephesians 2:10 in the front; Claire pray and reads the Bible; Scriptures are quoted and Blessings over food are said.
Negative Content- One or Two bloody parts, not-detailed.
Sexual Content- Quite a few (not-detailed) kisses.
-Claire Laurent
-Sutton Monroe
P.O.V. switches between them.
426 pages
Set in 1866
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
12 and up-
Three stars
New Teens (13&14) and up-
Three and a half stars
My personal Rating-
Four Stars
(Because the size can be intimidating, Pre & New Teens may (or may not- like me. ;) ) freak out the size of the book. That's why the first two ratings are lower.) I absolutely adore the fact that in the Preface, the Author, Miss Tamera Alexander, thanks the reader for “entrusting her with your time”. How sweet and amazing is that?! I didn’t know if I wanted to read “A Lasting Impression” or another book first, so I read the beginning of each and when I read that- I didn’t even pick up the other one!
The sequel just came out and when I got it in the mail, well… this was my face:
"Guess what just came in the mail!!!! I screamed so loud my friends thought I hurt myself! I wouldn't stay still so the picture's blurry. ;D "
Needless to say, I was excited. :) Review of that book, “A Beauty So Rare” coming next Wednesday!
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
“To create something that will last is Claire Laurent's most fervent desire as an artist. It's also her greatest weakness. When her fraud of a father deals her an unexpected hand, Claire is forced to flee from New Orleans to Nashville, only a year after the War Between the States has ended. Claire's path collides with that of Sutton Monroe, and she considers him a godsend for not turning her in to the authorities. But when they meet again and he refuses to come to her aid, she realizes she's sorely misjudged the man. Trading an unwanted destiny for an unknown future, Claire finds herself in the middle of Nashville's elite society and believes her dream of creating a lasting impression in the world of art may finally be within reach.
All that Sutton Monroe holds dear lies in ruin. He's determined to reclaim his heritage and to make the men who murdered his father pay. But what he discovers on his quest for vengeance reveals a truth that may cost him more than he ever imagined.”
Series: “Belmont Mansion” book #1. Can be a stand-alone novel. (book #2, “A Beauty So Rare”’s review will be posted next Wednesday.)
Spiritual Content- Ephesians 2:10 in the front; Claire pray and reads the Bible; Scriptures are quoted and Blessings over food are said.
Negative Content- One or Two bloody parts, not-detailed.
Sexual Content- Quite a few (not-detailed) kisses.
-Claire Laurent
-Sutton Monroe
P.O.V. switches between them.
426 pages
Set in 1866
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
12 and up-
Three stars
New Teens (13&14) and up-
Three and a half stars
My personal Rating-
Four Stars
(Because the size can be intimidating, Pre & New Teens may (or may not- like me. ;) ) freak out the size of the book. That's why the first two ratings are lower.) I absolutely adore the fact that in the Preface, the Author, Miss Tamera Alexander, thanks the reader for “entrusting her with your time”. How sweet and amazing is that?! I didn’t know if I wanted to read “A Lasting Impression” or another book first, so I read the beginning of each and when I read that- I didn’t even pick up the other one!
The sequel just came out and when I got it in the mail, well… this was my face:
"Guess what just came in the mail!!!! I screamed so loud my friends thought I hurt myself! I wouldn't stay still so the picture's blurry. ;D "
Needless to say, I was excited. :) Review of that book, “A Beauty So Rare” coming next Wednesday!
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
September 2, 2012
When I finished the last page of A Lasting Impression, I breathed a sigh of contentment. The story of Claire Laurent overcoming the hurts of her past was beautiful, genuine and a joy to read.
Alexander was spot on with the setting. I have never been to Belmont mansion, but I felt like I was there within the pages of this book. The opulence and grandeur were palpable, as well as Alexander's description of the surrounding landscape.
The characters were wonderful as well, each one coming to life in their own way. Mrs. Adelicia Acklen, the owner of the mansion and Claire's employer was one of my favorite characters. She was complex and more than she seemed at first glance. I loved getting to know her over the course of the story and thought it was neat that she was a real historical figure.
Claire is trying to put her life as a art copyist behind her and make a new life for herself as well as find security and confidence to step out and take the chance of her own are being accepted. I related to her plight and felt inspired as she gained more confidence not only in her painting but as a person and child of God. Speaking of that, I thought the spiritual aspects were intertwined into the story perfectly. Everything flowed naturally, and I never felt like I was gearing up to read a sermon. Kudos for Alexander for blending that in seamlessly.
I thought the romantic aspect was very well-done. It wasn't a case of insta-love--it built and grew through the course of the story. The scenes between Claire and Sutton were breathtaking--romantic and sweet without being at all sappy.
I was sort of expecting a dramatic ending, so I was pleasantly surprised when there was just enough build-up action and the wrap-up was happy but also realistic. I was glad that Alexander didn't just sweep away the consequences of the negative choices Claire had made in her past and tie everything up in a bow. It was realistic and true to life, but still satisfied my desire for a "happy ending" for lack of a better term :)
I recommend A Lasting Impression, especially for fans of inspiring historical romances.
Alexander was spot on with the setting. I have never been to Belmont mansion, but I felt like I was there within the pages of this book. The opulence and grandeur were palpable, as well as Alexander's description of the surrounding landscape.
The characters were wonderful as well, each one coming to life in their own way. Mrs. Adelicia Acklen, the owner of the mansion and Claire's employer was one of my favorite characters. She was complex and more than she seemed at first glance. I loved getting to know her over the course of the story and thought it was neat that she was a real historical figure.
Claire is trying to put her life as a art copyist behind her and make a new life for herself as well as find security and confidence to step out and take the chance of her own are being accepted. I related to her plight and felt inspired as she gained more confidence not only in her painting but as a person and child of God. Speaking of that, I thought the spiritual aspects were intertwined into the story perfectly. Everything flowed naturally, and I never felt like I was gearing up to read a sermon. Kudos for Alexander for blending that in seamlessly.
I thought the romantic aspect was very well-done. It wasn't a case of insta-love--it built and grew through the course of the story. The scenes between Claire and Sutton were breathtaking--romantic and sweet without being at all sappy.
I was sort of expecting a dramatic ending, so I was pleasantly surprised when there was just enough build-up action and the wrap-up was happy but also realistic. I was glad that Alexander didn't just sweep away the consequences of the negative choices Claire had made in her past and tie everything up in a bow. It was realistic and true to life, but still satisfied my desire for a "happy ending" for lack of a better term :)
I recommend A Lasting Impression, especially for fans of inspiring historical romances.
May 9, 2021
Rich in a historical setting and character depth, "A Lasting Impression" is one of those books you can't help savoring while wanting to know what the ending is going to bring the characters.
November 11, 2011
Let me confess up front – the cover of this book made me fall in love with Claire. What woman doesn’t sometimes imagine herself wearing one of the beautiful ball gowns from the Civil War era? And this one was spectacular.
That aside, the story inside was wonderful. Claire Laurent leaves a bad situation and just happens to fall into a dream world. As liason to Mrs. Adelicia Acklen, who is trying to reclaim her place in society, Claire is delighted to find that Belmont is filled with artwork beyond belief. Claire works very hard to prove herself worthy of the position, and at the same time starts to fall in love before she herself even realizes it.
While this is a wonderful love story and “girl making a new life for herself” book, what I find myself remembering most is the sentence that God speaks to Claire at a critical time in her life. I won’t give it away here, but I’ve been applying it to different aspects of my own life and it brings fresh perspective. The combination of great story and a new way to look at life makes this a splendid book.
That aside, the story inside was wonderful. Claire Laurent leaves a bad situation and just happens to fall into a dream world. As liason to Mrs. Adelicia Acklen, who is trying to reclaim her place in society, Claire is delighted to find that Belmont is filled with artwork beyond belief. Claire works very hard to prove herself worthy of the position, and at the same time starts to fall in love before she herself even realizes it.
While this is a wonderful love story and “girl making a new life for herself” book, what I find myself remembering most is the sentence that God speaks to Claire at a critical time in her life. I won’t give it away here, but I’ve been applying it to different aspects of my own life and it brings fresh perspective. The combination of great story and a new way to look at life makes this a splendid book.
July 9, 2016
This was a good story. I enjoyed the historical setting, the characters, the growing relationship between Claire and Sutton, and also the relationship she had with Mrs. Acklen. It was fun to imagine what it would have been like to live, or even work, in a grandiose place such as Belmont Mansion with all the descriptions that the author included throughout. The story was hard to get into in the beginning, it was slow and took awhile to set up but then became fun to read. There really wasn't a climax to the story which I really was expecting to have but despite this I was content with the ending and the stress-free read it provided.
August 6, 2021
Yikes. DNF. The part that made my jaw drop in shock was how the male love interest was peeved that his father's slaves didn't stick around after the civil war "to show gratitude" for their "fair treatment" under the hands of his parents, "more like hired hands than slaves." I think the point being missed here is that the slaves weren't, in fact, hired hands. They were property, and that lasting legacy of oppression is still being felt to this very day.
I love Christian fiction and this book had many things going for it, but the racial insensitivity wiped all of that right out.
I love Christian fiction and this book had many things going for it, but the racial insensitivity wiped all of that right out.
January 10, 2020
Wasn't fantastic, but it also wasn't terrible. The biggest thing was the romance for me... it didn't feel natural and was just was a little bit cringey to read... HOWEVER the actual plot itself about Claire being a art forger was so interesting and I wish that was explored more (but then I did put this book down for about 5 months so forgive me if I'm not remembering all the details!!).
This is one of those where if you like the author, you'll probably like this. For me, it just wasn't my favorite cup of tea. :)
This is one of those where if you like the author, you'll probably like this. For me, it just wasn't my favorite cup of tea. :)
February 1, 2020
4.5 Stars!
First book I have read by this author and she has definitely made a lasting impression on me :).
Tamera Alexander clearly has a gift to bring a world to life with her writing. As I read I felt like bell who spun to life in the Libary in ‘Beauty & the Beast’ or Maria who twirled as the hills came to life in ‘the sound of music’. I was transported to life in New Orleans and Nashville in the 1860’s and the journey was beautiful.
I really enjoyed Clare and Sutton’s story. Their journey was fun but yet heart breaking at times. I loved how both characters developed through the story.
As an added bonus I love the introduction to Belmont Mansion I cannot wait to visit again :)
I give 5 stars to Linda Stephens for a excellent engaging audio performance.
Definitely recommend for those who enjoy Christian historical Fiction :)
First book I have read by this author and she has definitely made a lasting impression on me :).
Tamera Alexander clearly has a gift to bring a world to life with her writing. As I read I felt like bell who spun to life in the Libary in ‘Beauty & the Beast’ or Maria who twirled as the hills came to life in ‘the sound of music’. I was transported to life in New Orleans and Nashville in the 1860’s and the journey was beautiful.
I really enjoyed Clare and Sutton’s story. Their journey was fun but yet heart breaking at times. I loved how both characters developed through the story.
As an added bonus I love the introduction to Belmont Mansion I cannot wait to visit again :)
I give 5 stars to Linda Stephens for a excellent engaging audio performance.
Definitely recommend for those who enjoy Christian historical Fiction :)
June 27, 2020
A Lasting Impression by Tamera Alexander is the first book in the Christian historical fiction series called the Belmont Mansion.
I really enjoyed this book. It was rich in historical details about the actual Belmont Mansion in Nashville and its builder, Adelicia Acklen. Set in the 1860s, right after the Civil War, the country was still full of tension and some of its cities were decimated.
The main character is a young lady who was dragged into becoming an art forger by her father and his business partner. She takes the first chance she can and escapes to Nashville, where she applies to become the personal assistant to the lady Adelicia of Belmont Mansion. And Adelicia’s lawyer, Sutton, is quite suspicious of the new girl.
It was a very interesting, slightly romantic story. I loved all the details about famous art and about the historical setting. And the challenges the main character faced as the assistant to the most wealthy and influential woman in the city were fascinating.
I recommend this clean, Christian romance. Enjoy!
I really enjoyed this book. It was rich in historical details about the actual Belmont Mansion in Nashville and its builder, Adelicia Acklen. Set in the 1860s, right after the Civil War, the country was still full of tension and some of its cities were decimated.
The main character is a young lady who was dragged into becoming an art forger by her father and his business partner. She takes the first chance she can and escapes to Nashville, where she applies to become the personal assistant to the lady Adelicia of Belmont Mansion. And Adelicia’s lawyer, Sutton, is quite suspicious of the new girl.
It was a very interesting, slightly romantic story. I loved all the details about famous art and about the historical setting. And the challenges the main character faced as the assistant to the most wealthy and influential woman in the city were fascinating.
I recommend this clean, Christian romance. Enjoy!
July 28, 2021
This book has become one of my favorites. Claire is caught up in the world of painting other famous artists paintings and forging their names. Her father and uncle Antoine DePaul were responsible for selling it to unsuspecting gallery customers. The gallery gets robbed and her father stabbed resulting in her being sent away to Nashville. She discovers the fate of her father and escapes the grips of her former life, incidentally becoming personal liaison to the wealthiest woman in Nashville. She falls for Sutton, Mrs. Acklen’s personal lawyer and attempts to become the painter God created her to be. But she must first make things right.
March 28, 2017
I was pleasantly surprised by this book. I liked the strong female characters in the book who are strong, yet imperfect and acknowledge that imperfection. I liked the glimpses of life after the Civil War that I had not considered such as how former slaves relate to white people they've known all their lives and vice versa.
I was also intrigued by Mrs. Aklen's life. Her marriages and the number of children she had lost. I think it really brought home to me what life was like in that time period for women. They really had no say in many aspects of their life and having a husband was very important to their standing in society and even survival. The fact that some of her children died from illness's, like bronchitis, an illness that my own children have struggled with but thanks to modern medicine suffered no ill effects, was particularly compelling.
Sutton's battles for his family's honor and land was also eye opening because I hadn't thought too much what it was like for people in the Confederacy after the war. What I learned in history class was mostly about the freed slaves, but not about the wealthy land owners who owned the slaves.
This was a well written book, full of suspense and intriguing historical aspects.
I was also intrigued by Mrs. Aklen's life. Her marriages and the number of children she had lost. I think it really brought home to me what life was like in that time period for women. They really had no say in many aspects of their life and having a husband was very important to their standing in society and even survival. The fact that some of her children died from illness's, like bronchitis, an illness that my own children have struggled with but thanks to modern medicine suffered no ill effects, was particularly compelling.
Sutton's battles for his family's honor and land was also eye opening because I hadn't thought too much what it was like for people in the Confederacy after the war. What I learned in history class was mostly about the freed slaves, but not about the wealthy land owners who owned the slaves.
This was a well written book, full of suspense and intriguing historical aspects.
January 4, 2022
When a reader sticks with the same genre time after time, the books sound alike, just a few variations in order to make them slightly unique. After reading so many of these I almost dread picking up another one.
Upon occasion, though, a book comes along that, for whatever reason, captivates me so much that I think of it all day long, until the time I can finally sit back down and pick it up with an internal, "Aaaahhh".
This was that "upon occasion".
A Lasting Impression will be just that for I me. All the others that sound so similar never leave an impression on me. After a month or two (sometimes within a week) I forget I've even read them.
The story:
Clare has decided to quit forging paintings of famous artists which her father had forced her to copy. On the way back from her lunch break, after making this decision, a tragedy struck the gallery. At her father's command Clare was sent to a city where she knew no one and was virtually penniless. After an unwelcome advancement by the "gentleman" at whose home she was sent, she took her leave, virtually escaping with nothing.
Circumstances aid her in securing a most coveted job, which she came to believe was the hand of God.
Throughout the next few months, with her popularity in the town for her artistic touches to her social event planning, you'd think she'd become arrogant or boastful. On the contrary. Because of her past, she never felt worthy of the approval. Guilt over the forgeries, and her father's role in that life plagued her.
Eventually her past catches up with her. Little did she know her employer's personal business manager (and lawyer) had been investigating the forgery ring. After falling deeply in love with him, should she risk everything to come clean with him...or play it safe and hope her past stays that? In the past.
Very enjoyable book!
Upon occasion, though, a book comes along that, for whatever reason, captivates me so much that I think of it all day long, until the time I can finally sit back down and pick it up with an internal, "Aaaahhh".
This was that "upon occasion".
A Lasting Impression will be just that for I me. All the others that sound so similar never leave an impression on me. After a month or two (sometimes within a week) I forget I've even read them.
The story:
Clare has decided to quit forging paintings of famous artists which her father had forced her to copy. On the way back from her lunch break, after making this decision, a tragedy struck the gallery. At her father's command Clare was sent to a city where she knew no one and was virtually penniless. After an unwelcome advancement by the "gentleman" at whose home she was sent, she took her leave, virtually escaping with nothing.
Circumstances aid her in securing a most coveted job, which she came to believe was the hand of God.
Throughout the next few months, with her popularity in the town for her artistic touches to her social event planning, you'd think she'd become arrogant or boastful. On the contrary. Because of her past, she never felt worthy of the approval. Guilt over the forgeries, and her father's role in that life plagued her.
Eventually her past catches up with her. Little did she know her employer's personal business manager (and lawyer) had been investigating the forgery ring. After falling deeply in love with him, should she risk everything to come clean with him...or play it safe and hope her past stays that? In the past.
Very enjoyable book!
January 9, 2012
Where I got the book: my local library.
Claire longs to be recognized for her artistic talent, but her father and his business partner force her to forge paintings. A move to Nashville gives Claire the chance for a new start, and she begins to fall for Sutton. But her past is still unresolved.
My pointer was hovering between three and four stars for this review. Let's start with the 4-star side: I did get caught up in the story by the time I got to the last hundred pages of the book. The plot was nicely constructed, and I found myself wanting to like the characters.
On the 3-star side, having read a few inspirational romances I am beginning to long for a different character arc. Enough with the feisty yet submissive heroine with a secret, who longs for God to be real but has Doubts. My other gripe was that I like my historical reading to ring true; this was the Hallmark TV show version of post-war America, with a picture-perfect setting, handsome men and beautiful women, and Gone With the Wind-style former slaves who are fiercely loyal to ex-Massah.
I found Alexander's prose style a little heavy on the adjectives and the whole breathless-admiration-of-anything-European never sits well with me, probably because I'm European myself and not easily impressed by a bit of French. And this is a good illustration of how reviews are subjective; to some people this kind of glossy detail is food for the imagination. So I will end by recommending this book to readers who love to be transported to a movie-set world, and the four stars stay.
Claire longs to be recognized for her artistic talent, but her father and his business partner force her to forge paintings. A move to Nashville gives Claire the chance for a new start, and she begins to fall for Sutton. But her past is still unresolved.
My pointer was hovering between three and four stars for this review. Let's start with the 4-star side: I did get caught up in the story by the time I got to the last hundred pages of the book. The plot was nicely constructed, and I found myself wanting to like the characters.
On the 3-star side, having read a few inspirational romances I am beginning to long for a different character arc. Enough with the feisty yet submissive heroine with a secret, who longs for God to be real but has Doubts. My other gripe was that I like my historical reading to ring true; this was the Hallmark TV show version of post-war America, with a picture-perfect setting, handsome men and beautiful women, and Gone With the Wind-style former slaves who are fiercely loyal to ex-Massah.
I found Alexander's prose style a little heavy on the adjectives and the whole breathless-admiration-of-anything-European never sits well with me, probably because I'm European myself and not easily impressed by a bit of French. And this is a good illustration of how reviews are subjective; to some people this kind of glossy detail is food for the imagination. So I will end by recommending this book to readers who love to be transported to a movie-set world, and the four stars stay.
November 6, 2011
Rich in historical setting and character depth, “A Lasting Impression” is one of those books you can’t help really savoring, while wanting to know what the ending is going to bring the characters.
The pace of this novel is evenly tempered through the entire book, and takes place in as beautiful a setting as ever to create on the page. Once you’ve stepped inside the doors of Belmont and have seen it through Claire’s eyes, you really don’t want to go back to the real world.
Rich is really the only word I can use to describe it. Not in material wealth, though there is an abundance, but in depth of writing, characters, romance (sweet heavens, what a romance!) and enough tension to keep you wondering when the next “shoe” will drop.
I loved the gradual and subtle changes that come through Claire’s life, especially in her spiritual walk. It’s a wonderful example of how God’s love can change us, but it doesn’t happen overnight.
The story flows deep and true. Deep in character’s lives, in how they change, true in the purpose to tell a really good story and invite the reader along and into a journey that feels like it could last forever.
A fun side note: that gorgeous dress on the cover? It does play a role in the book, which absolutely thrilled me. *wink*
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the publishers through Litfuse tours for my copy to review.
The pace of this novel is evenly tempered through the entire book, and takes place in as beautiful a setting as ever to create on the page. Once you’ve stepped inside the doors of Belmont and have seen it through Claire’s eyes, you really don’t want to go back to the real world.
Rich is really the only word I can use to describe it. Not in material wealth, though there is an abundance, but in depth of writing, characters, romance (sweet heavens, what a romance!) and enough tension to keep you wondering when the next “shoe” will drop.
I loved the gradual and subtle changes that come through Claire’s life, especially in her spiritual walk. It’s a wonderful example of how God’s love can change us, but it doesn’t happen overnight.
The story flows deep and true. Deep in character’s lives, in how they change, true in the purpose to tell a really good story and invite the reader along and into a journey that feels like it could last forever.
A fun side note: that gorgeous dress on the cover? It does play a role in the book, which absolutely thrilled me. *wink*
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the publishers through Litfuse tours for my copy to review.
March 11, 2016
I probably shouldn't review this book so poorly having not finished the book, but I'm not sure that I will take the time to finish it (I got about 2/3 through). I honestly just couldn't get past the totally romantic view it took of the post Civil War south. I loved Gone with the Wind growing up, but I would really hope that a story written now would try to weave in the devastating mark slavery left in its wake, and not pine for the days before the evil Union soldiers upended their genteel way of life. An actual passage from the book of the romantic lead's internal monologue, "Still, they [meaning the slaves he owned] could have at least stayed to help his mother in the days following. Shown some measure of gratitude for how his parents had always treated them . . .more like hired hands than slaves." Yikes! I get that this is just a fluffy romance novel, which I have no problem with and enjoy. But if you are going to set it in the post Civil War south, you need to be responsible enough to at least acknowledge the realities of the times- at least a little bit! Again, the last 1/3 of the book could have brought me this and I missed it, but it really wasn't worth it to me to find out.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 655 reviews